The previous chapter claimed that the universal and loving Spirit reveals to all creatures in uncontrolling ways. Creatures directly perceive divine revelation through nonsensory perception. God’s communications rarely rise to consciousness, however, remaining as feelings, hunches, and intuitions.
No one literally sees, hears, or detects God with their five senses, but our senses give knowledge we can use to infer divine activity. Using sensory and nonsensory perception — alongside reflection and dialogue with others — we discern what the Spirit reveals to varying degrees of accuracy.
(This essay is part of a chapter of my Systematic Theology of Love, Vol 2. A portion of this chapter is free, but paid Substack subscribers get entire chapters as they’re written. Paid subscribers can suggest changes. They get their names in the book’s acknowledgments and receive a signed copy of the published book in hardcover. At only $8 a month or $80 for the year, please consider a paid subscription!)

In this chapter, I argue that we best understand revelation as relational encounters with the Spirit that require interpretation. By “revelation,” I don’t have scripture primarily in mind, although I don’t exclude it. I mean revelation in general, which includes mystical experiences, the witness of nature, meditation, worship and art, community events, mundane moments, and much more.
Although others have understood revelation as relational encounter, the idea has been described in unhelpful ways. Some theologians speak only of God’s action, ignoring or rejecting creaturely contributions in these encounters. Many theologians use language that implies God may or may not choose to reveal. I argue that the Spirit necessarily reveals to all creatures, and effective communication requires creaturely response.
The idea that humans must interpret the Spirit’s communication is widely acknowledged. Interpretation-free revelation is an illusion. People interpret revelation in radically different ways, however, because human perspectives vary widely. If creatures are diverse, the Spirit can’t control, and divine love is pluriform, we should expect diverse interpretations. Rather than diversity being evidence of human sin, it points to God’s multi-faceted communication and diverse creaturely experiences.
Not all interpretations of revelation are equal, however, especially when it comes to discerning who God is and what God wants. How should people of faith evaluate claims about the Spirit, especially when they contradict one another or basic experience? I’ll argue that positive values play the key role in discerning the divine, with love as the primary measure for interpreting well. And bad interpretations contradict our fundamental experiences of reality.
Gathering insights from this chapter and the previous, I conclude by solving the problem of divine hiddenness. My solution portrays God as uncontrolling, invisible, and incorporeal. I argue that the amipotent Spirit always reveals, never voluntarily hides, can’t provide crystal-clear revelation, and can’t guarantee that creatures interpret accurately. If humans attune themselves to the ways of love, however, they’re more likely to become aware of the Spirit at work in their lives.
We must interpret the revelation of the universal Spirit who always loves.
Encountering the Revealing Spirit
In the twentieth century, theologians Karl Barth, Emil Brunner, Georgia Harkness, Howard Thurman, and others moved from talking about revelation[1] primarily as words and texts to it as encounters with the Spirit.[2] This emphasis upon experiential encounters was not a new insight but a return to much earlier understandings of how the Spirit reveals. Many twentieth-century theologians were reacting to claims about revelation as primarily, if not exclusively, the Bible.
The focus upon the Bible as God’s primary revelation had arisen, mainly, with the emergence of Protestantism. Martin Luther and other reformers privileged scripture over the Pope, and they preached the priesthood of all believers. This led to a shift away from relying upon pastors and priests for access to divine revelation. As scripture was translated into the vernacular and distributed widely — thanks to the printing press — more people read the Bible for themselves or heard it in public. The Latin phrase sola scriptura — scripture alone — became a rallying cry, with some claiming the Bible as the only means by which God reveals.
While not rejecting scripture or a proper role for the church, a host of twentieth-century theologians argued that revelation is primarily about direct encounters with the divine. Karl Barth, for instance, considered the Bible a means by which God addresses humans, but he did not call it divine. “The Bible is God’s Word to the extent that God causes it to be his Word,” says Barth, “to the extent that he speaks through it.”[3] Revelation, therefore, means encountering the One to whom the writers testify. Barth emphasized God’s free decisions to establish these encounters, and he denounced the idea that humans experience deity through natural reason.[4]
Whereas Barth emphasized God’s freedom, Brunner, Harkness, and Thurman gave greater attention to the relational conditions of revelation. Revelation “is knowledge in the dimension of personal encounter,” says Brunner. “God Himself discloses Himself to me.”[5] Harkness identified the importance of human receptivity, including critical reflection.[6] For her, love plays a central role in discerning what the Spirit might be revealing.[7] Howard Thurman stressed the necessary action of both Creator and creatures: “religious experience in its profoundest dimension is the finding of man by God and the finding of God by man.”[8]
I agree that revelation involves encounters with the Spirit. This way of understanding God’s communication fits my claim that we directly experience the Spirit, moment by moment, through nonsensory perception.[9] The primary content of revelation is not words or texts, therefore, but the actual presence of the universal Spirit who always loves.[10] Revelation is primarily experiential and secondarily about propositions.
Humans typically try to express what they believe the Spirit has revealed, however. They do so through art, dance, music, and other forms of communication. Perhaps most often, however, people use language. This takes the form of words, phrases, and sentences they speak aloud, write, sing, chant, or type.
Words cannot articulate experiences of the divine perfectly. Experiences of God are prelinguistic, and words cannot capture them fully. In fact, people sometimes use unhelpful words to describe their experiences of the Spirit. “God took control of me,” they might say, or “I heard the Lord’s actual voice.” These descriptions lead to problems I addressed in previous chapters. We can reject bad descriptions of revelation while acknowledging the authenticity of relational encounters with the Spirit.
Some written words used to describe experiences of the Spirit are, over time, elevated to the status of sacred scripture. These articulations become important sources for understanding God, as communities preserve them across generations. While reading them, we may encounter the Spirit in profound ways. But the words of any text are not divine.